Why the scale lies

Why the Scale is Lying to You (and What to Measure Instead)

September 09, 20252 min read
Second Chance Wellness

For years, the scale has been sold as the ultimate judge of progress. Step on it in the morning, and you either win or lose before the day even starts.

But here’s the truth most men find out the hard way:

The scale doesn’t measure strength. It doesn’t measure energy. It doesn’t measure how capable or confident you feel in your own skin.

It only measures gravity’s pull on your body. That’s it.

I’ve coached countless men—former athletes, busy professionals, even guys using GLP-1s—who celebrated as the number went down, only to realize they were actually weaker, slower, and more frustrated than before. Dropping weight without building strength is not winning.

The real transformation happens when you flip the script.

Instead of asking, “How light can I get?”, start asking:

  • How strong can I become?

  • How much better can I move?

  • How much energy can I bring into my work, my training, my family life?

Because when you train for performance—chasing stronger lifts, better recovery, and higher energy—you build momentum that lasts. You become harder to break, more capable, and more confident. The scale will follow, but now it’s a byproduct, not the focus.

And here’s the kicker: this isn’t just theory. I’ve seen guys who were ready to quit, frustrated with diets and weight loss drugs, suddenly reignite their fire when they started tracking the right things. The moment they hit a new PR, slept through the night, or realized they could train without pain—that’s when everything clicked.

So here’s your challenge this week:

Stop letting the scale dictate your success.

Instead, measure what actually matters: strength, recovery, energy, and consistency.

Don’t chase smaller. Chase stronger.

If this message hits, drop a comment or reply back with the one performance goal you want to crush in the next 90 days. I’ll personally read every response.

Chris Bartl is a strength coach, nutrition expert, and founder of Second Chance Wellness. With over 15 years of experience coaching everyone from pro athletes to everyday warriors, Chris is on a mission to help people over 35 rebuild their metabolism, reclaim their health, and finally feel strong in their bodies again — without the gimmicks or the grind.

Chris Bartl

Chris Bartl is a strength coach, nutrition expert, and founder of Second Chance Wellness. With over 15 years of experience coaching everyone from pro athletes to everyday warriors, Chris is on a mission to help people over 35 rebuild their metabolism, reclaim their health, and finally feel strong in their bodies again — without the gimmicks or the grind.

Instagram logo icon
Back to Blog